Menu Contact White & White, Attorneys at Law
Free Initial Consultation 865-622-7768

Tennessee judge grants woman a father's right to custody

In a hotly contested legal divorce between a lesbian couple, the Tennessee court did what many consider the only rational decision: They granted the non-biological mother the same parenting and custodial rights and responsibilities that a man would have over a child that his wife conceived during the marriage.

The case concerned the custody fight over a child conceived and born to a married lesbian couple through the use of an anonymous donor and artificial insemination.

The couple had married in 2014 in Washington D.C., where same-sex marriages were legal, then settled in Tennessee, where they were not. They had a child together in 2015 -- but, just like many heterosexual couples, their marriage fell apart. The custody issue became acrimonious.

Unfortunately for the non-biological mother, since Tennessee didn't recognize same-sex marriages at that time of their daughter's birth, their daughter's birth certificate only included the biological mother's name as a parent.

The biological mother sought to bar her former spouse from seeing the child by contending that Tennessee's laws on children conceived by artificial insemination were clearly designed only to confer presumptive parental rights to the husband -- a male -- of the woman who conceived.

The non-biological mother was initially denied any custody rights. She then filed a legal challenge over the law's constitutionality, since it was passed years before same-sex marriage was even close to being a national law. In response, dozens of conservative lawmakers in the state tried to intervene in the case by rushing through a bill that would order the court to determine cases based on the natural meaning of words like "husband" and "father" without regard to interpretation under same-sex marriage laws -- even though the state's own Attorney General had opined that family court judges would likely ignore such a law.

The judge in the case essentially blocked the legislature from intervening in the family drama and told them to stay out of his courtroom, declaring it a violation of the separation of powers under the state constitution.

The State Attorney General, for her part, supported the family court's decision and the use of gender-neutral interpretations. Because the challenge affects large portions of the state's law, she was required to file an opinion -- and her opinion was that the non-biological mother should be accorded the rights and duties of any father in that situation.

If you're dealing with a complicated custody issue of your own, seek legal assistance as soon a possible.

Source: USA TODAY, "Lesbian granted rights of 'husband' in same-sex divorce," Jamie Satterfield, Knoxville (Tenn.) News Sentinel, May 10, 2017

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Honors & Memberships
  • 10 Best – 2016 | Client Satisfaction | American Institute of Family Law Attorneys(TM)

    He has received this award 2016-2019 for 10 best Attorneys, Client Satisfaction Award.

  • The National Top 40 Under 40 Advocates

    He has received this award 6 years in a row now. for Top 100 Attorneys.

  • 10 Best Attorney | Client Satisfaction | American Institute of Family Law Attorneys(TM)

    Member since 2018 for Top 10 Family Law Attorney for Tennessee.

  • Family Law Top 10 Attorney - 2017-2019 | Attorney and Practice Magazines

    Member since 2017 for Top 10 Family Law Attorney in Tennessee.

  • Best Legal Counsel

    Member since 2018 for Best Legal Counsel in Family Law.

  • Lawyers of Distinction

    Member since 2017 for Excellence in Family and Divorce Top 10% in the USA.

  • Best Attorneys of America | Lifetime Charter Member

    Lifetime charter member for Best Attorneys in America for Tennessee.

Contact Us For A Free Case Evaluation - Email or Call 865-622-7768

White & White, Attorneys at Law, is committed to working with individuals to help them reshape their lives. Perhaps you need a second chance after getting arrested; maybe you're trying to pull yourself together during a frustrating divorce. Whatever the issue, the experienced lawyers at White & White, Attorneys at Law, are here to help.

Individuals are encouraged to contact the firm online or call to schedule a free initial consultation and discuss their legal needs with an experienced Sevierville family law attorney. Appointments are scheduled during regular business hours, but evening and weekend appointments are available upon request.


Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

White & White, Attorneys at Law 216 Phoenix Court Suite D Seymour, TN 37865 Toll Free: 888-551-9046 Phone: 865-622-7768 Fax: 865-577-1655 Seymour Law Office Map

Tennessee judge grants woman a father's right to custody | White & White, Attorneys at Law